On a cash-on-delivery order that comes back, you lose the delivery charge, the return charge, the packing and the ad spend that got you the order, and earn nothing. If your profit on a delivered order equals your loss on a returned one, a 20% return rate cuts your real profit per order by 40%, and a 50% return rate wipes it out.
Enter your own numbers in the free online seller profit calculator to see your profit per order placed and the highest return rate you can survive.
Profit Per Delivered Order Is Not Your Profit
Most sellers calculate profit like this:
| Line | Amount |
|---|---|
| Selling price | Rs. 2,500 |
| Product cost | − Rs. 1,200 |
| Courier (delivery) | − Rs. 250 |
| Packing | − Rs. 50 |
| Ads per order | − Rs. 250 |
| Profit if delivered | Rs. 750 |
But some orders are refused at the door or returned. On each of those:
| Line | Amount |
|---|---|
| Courier (delivery) | − Rs. 250 |
| Courier (return) | − Rs. 200 |
| Packing | − Rs. 50 |
| Ads that got the order | − Rs. 250 |
| Loss if returned | − Rs. 750 |
The product usually comes back and can be resold, so its cost is not lost, but everything else is.
What Returns Do to the Numbers
Using the example above, per 100 orders placed:
| Return rate | Delivered | Returned | Profit per 100 orders | Profit per order placed |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0% | 100 | 0 | Rs. 75,000 | Rs. 750 |
| 10% | 90 | 10 | Rs. 60,000 | Rs. 600 |
| 20% | 80 | 20 | Rs. 45,000 | Rs. 450 |
| 30% | 70 | 30 | Rs. 30,000 | Rs. 300 |
| 50% | 50 | 50 | Rs. 0 | Rs. 0 |
Highest return rate you can survive = delivered profit ÷ (delivered profit + return loss). Here, 750 ÷ 1,500 = 50%.
Marketplace vs Social Selling
Marketplaces (Daraz and similar) charge a commission that varies by category plus a payment handling fee, and often run their own logistics. Commission rates change, so check the current rate card in your seller centre.
Instagram, Facebook and WhatsApp sellers pay no commission but usually pay more for ads per order and arrange their own courier. Returns on impulse-driven social orders can be higher.
The calculator has a preset for each and lets you edit every fee.
How to Cut Returns
- Confirm every COD order by call or WhatsApp before dispatch. Unconfirmed orders are dropped.
- Use accurate photos, sizes and colours. Most refusals are "not what I expected".
- Offer a small discount for advance payment through a bank transfer or wallet.
- Track returns by city and product. Pause ads in areas or for products that return far more than average.
- Dispatch quickly. The longer the wait, the more likely the customer changes their mind.
Cutting returns from 20% to 10% in the example above adds Rs. 150 per order placed, as much as a big price increase, without losing a single sale.
Track the Month, Not Just the Orders
Order dashboards show sales. They rarely show what is left after ads, courier bills and returns. With HissabAI on WhatsApp you log each day's sales ("sale 52000") and costs ("6000 facebook ads", "4500 courier"), and the monthly report shows what you really made. For pricing individual items, use the profit margin calculator, and to check the whole business covers its fixed costs, the break-even calculator.
What is a normal COD return rate in Pakistan?
Sellers commonly report 10–30% of cash-on-delivery orders being refused or returned, higher for impulse products and new stores.
How do I calculate profit with returns?
Profit per order placed = (1 − return rate) × profit per delivered order − return rate × loss per returned order.
Should I stop offering cash on delivery?
Usually not completely, because COD drives many sales in Pakistan. Confirm orders, offer an advance-payment discount, and limit COD where returns are highest.
How much does Daraz charge sellers?
Daraz charges a category-based commission and a payment fee, and rates change. Check the current rate card in Seller Center.